|
|
Hoover
Street Revival
DIR: Sophie Fiennes PRO: Sophie
Fiennes FEATURING: Bishop Noel Jones
In
Hoover Street Revival director Sophie Fiennes delivers
a fascinating contrast to the interactive styles of fashionable
filmmakers like Nick Broomfield and Michael Moore. Fiennes
observational style can be largely explained by the fact that
she was often behind the camera herself, a one-woman crew
relying on her credit card for funding. Fiennes does not appear
in the film, her voice is not heard and she does not interview
her subject, Bishop Noel Jones.
Hoover Street Revival is a collage
of images from South Central LA. Images from Jones' extraordinary
sermons are juxtaposed with gritty footage from the lives
of his congregation. Elaborate gospel arrangements appear
in the film alongside the aftermath of a drive by shooting,
helicopter shots of vast ghettoes and the travails of a single
father. This passive, non-judgemental rendering of the community
is the films greatest strength but it is also its greatest
weakness.
At no point does the audience feel that we get
beyond the mesmerising delivery of the film's subject. Perhaps
Fiennes thought that by interviewing Bishop Jones, she would
destroy the mystique that is central to his impressive presence.
By not doing so, Fiennes offers little of real substance to
go with the style. The audience wonders, for instance, who
will profit from the Bishop's cottage industry in which he
sells off CDs and videos of his sermons? We have no idea why
the Bishop is there, how he got there, and what he really
does beyond giving sermons and selling them. While there is
no doubt that some of his congregation's lives have improved
as a result of his teaching, could that not be said of many
ministers of the church?
If Fiennes' aim is to show that the spectacular
delivery of a showman bishop will improve some people's lives,
she has no doubt done so. However, one can't help feeling
that an opportunity to dig a little deeper was missed. It's
a fascinating, but ultimately unsatisfying, film.
Ross Whitaker
|