Peter Bodie gives his marks for dark comedy Bad Apples.

What are the responsibilities of a teacher? How should school administrators respond when a classroom crisis seems impossible to resolve? Can a parent be compelled to take greater responsibility for a disruptive child? And, perhaps most uncomfortably, whose rights should take priority: the child who disrupts the education of others, or the children whose education is being disrupted? These are just some of the questions posed in the dark comedy Bad Apples, an unsettling and unconventional film.

Set in an ordinary, quiet suburban English community, Maria (Saoirse Ronan) is a primary-school teacher at her wits' end. She is struggling to maintain order in her classroom because of Danny (Eddie Waller), a particularly disruptive and aggressive ten-year-old pupil. Danny causes constant trouble, disrupts lessons and makes life miserable for Maria and the other children. Matters take an even darker turn when he pushes Pauline (Nia Brown), another pupil, down the stairs, leaving her with a broken arm.

One evening, Maria happens upon Danny vandalising cars. When she intervenes, she accidentally knocks him unconscious. Rather than alerting the authorities, she panics and takes Danny home, locking him in her basement. With Danny absent, the classroom becomes calmer, the other children flourish and Maria's professional life improves drastically. When Pauline discovers that Maria is holding Danny captive, she does not report her. Instead, she uses this knowledge to manipulate her.

A challenging film, Bad Apples initially felt incomplete on first viewing. However, after some reflection and discussion, it became clear that this is a film that lingers. Directed by Swedish filmmaker Jonatan Etzler, it is his first English-language feature. The screenplay, adapted by Jess O'Kane, is based on the Swedish novel De Oönskade (meaning The Unwanted) by Rasmus Lindgren. This is a story that stays with you because it quietly poses some critical questions. How should society deal with a young child who continually disrupts the classroom, to the detriment of the other pupils? Whose rights should be prioritised? And where does responsibility lie when the education system appears unable to find a solution?

Filmed over 32 days in a derelict school in Bath, with additional scenes shot in Bristol, Bad Apples has a strong, authentic feel to it, at times resembling a television documentary more than a conventional feature film. The camera seems at ease in the school scenes, capturing the everyday dynamics of classroom life with a stark realism. Perhaps this is unsurprising, given that both director Jonatan Etzler and writer Jess O'Kane have experience of teaching. That familiarity with the school environment brings an added layer of credibility to the film.

This is deepened even further by the film's performances. Saoirse Ronan's character, Maria, develops in both appearance and psychological depth as the story progresses. Ronan plays her with great skill and intensity, making her increasingly disturbing actions almost believable. Eddie Waller dominates his scenes as Danny, a complex child who struggles with literacy. As a young actor Waller displays a remarkable range and screen presence, particularly impressive for his first time on screen. Nia Brown's portrayal of Pauline, the archetypal 'goody-two-shoes', will remind many of us of a child we knew at school. Pauline initially presents herself as having good intentions, but Brown captures her more calculating side well.

Bad Apples has done well on the festival circuit, premiering at the 2025 Toronto International Film Festival before appearing at San Sebastián, where it was nominated for the New Directors Award. It also secured a Best Film nomination at the 2025 BFI London Film Festival. More recently, writer Jess O'Kane received a Best Debut Screenwriter nomination at the 2026 British Independent Film Awards.

This film is marketed as a dark comedy, and it certainly is twisted and troublesome. However, I'm not entirely convinced that it sits comfortably within the comedy genre. There are moments of absurdity, but the underlying subject matter is far more unnerving and comes with a whole bucket of questions. What happens when a teacher takes drastic and illegal action? Imagine that those actions appear to bring about a beneficial result for both the disruptive child and the children whose education has been affected. What if this terrible secret becomes known to a small group? But most importantly: What would you do?

Bad Apples is may be a troubling ride but it's definitely worth the investment. A sequel would be very welcome, if only for a sense of closure.

Bad Apples was released in cinemas 18th September 2026 and available to stream online now.

Share this post