DIR: Joe Wright • WRI: Deborah Moggach • PROD: Tim Bevan, Eric Fellner, Paul Webster • DOP: Roman Osin • ED: Paul Tothill • DES: Sarah Greenwood • CAST: Keira Knightley, Matthew McFadyen, Dame Judi Dench, Donald Sutherland and Brenda Blethyn
I've never really got the whole Mr D'arcy thing. This is someone who has topped polls for women's favourite literary character in spite of an emotional reticence that would make Mr Spock look like a tired and emotional Russell Crowe. Women are always complaining that men don't express emotion enough (going, perhaps, by the logic that if something isn't spoken of it can't possibly exist), and yet the most popular sex symbol in literature is virtually incapable of expressing emotion. Is it any wonder modern man is so confused?
Nonetheless, Pride and Prejudice is a very popular book; it is gently satirical and genuinely romantic. There have been more than a few previous screen outings (most notably the BBC version with Jennifer Ehle and Colin Firth in 1995), and other films that have borrowed from it include Bridget Jones's Diary and Bride and Prejudice, not to mention the innumerable romantic comedies where the leads start out hating each other. Like Jane Austen's other novels, Pride & Prejudice is the template for the modern romantic comedy. Taking that into account it's hard not to wonder if another adaptation is entirely necessary.
Fortunately, it's a good film: there are some great camera moves and handheld shots, and the party scenes and street scenes are nice and rowdy, quite earthy. You get to see the world these people inhabit in a way that makes it real but isn't trying too hard to be 'real'. There are also glimpses of events outside the story, like an implication of Mary Bennet having a crush on Mr Collins.
On the debit side there are a good few scenes that seem to start and end with people entering and leaving, which is a little distracting. I don't know if this is a convention of the book, but it can seem odd when someone walks half an hour to someone else's estate, has a two-minute conversation, and then heads back.
The acting is all good. Of particular note are Donald Sutherland and Brenda Blethyn as the Bennet parents, and Tom Hollander's surprisingly sympathetic Mr Collins. He's not pleasant, but you cringe for him as much as because of him.
Keira Knightley gives a flawless performance as an admirably idealistic and strong-willed, if judgmental, heroine. The only false note is that she's supposed to be playing a character who is considered quite plain, at least in comparison with her older sister, Jane. But you can get past that pretty quickly.
Matthew McFadyen's Mr D'arcy seems sadder than Colin Firth's more stony portrayal, but in a way this shows a previously neglected side of the character: a private, introspective man, who doesn't like parties or talking about things that don't matter. On the other hand, many of his fans might prefer the harder, colder version which, I suppose, hints at a sort of inner ruggedness: the thinking man of action. Shyness just isn't as sexy as aloofness. But when you think of it, he is actually very lucky to meet Lizzie Bennet. If he didn't, he would probably end up alone or in an unhappy marriage with a woman who never challenges him.
Pride & Prejudice should please fans of romantic comedies and of Jane Austen. If it weren't already a classic it might not be considered anything new, but as a treatment of a classic it stands up more than adequately.
Tim Hanan
Pride & Prejudice is released on 16th September 2005.
